Allah or Jesus?
This is a true story and the author, Rick Mathes, is a well known leader in prison ministry.
Last month I attended my annual training session that's required for maintaining my state prison security clearance. During the training session there was a presentation by three speakers representing the Roman Catholic, Protestant and Muslim faiths, who explained each of their belief systems.
I was particularly interested in what the Islamic Imam had to say. The Imam gave a great presentation of the basics of Islam, complete with a video.
After the presentations, time was provided for questions and answers.
When it was my turn, I directed my question to the Imam and asked:
"Please, correct me if I'm wrong, but I understand that most Imams and clerics of Islam have declared a holy jihad [Holy war] against the infidels of the world. And, that by killing an infidel, which is a command to all Muslims, they are assured of a place in
heaven.
If that's the case, can you give me the definition of an infidel?"
There was no disagreement with my statements and, without hesitation, he replied, "Non-believers!"
I responded, "So, let me make sure I have this straight. All followers of Allah have been commanded to kill everyone who is not of your faith so they can go to Heaven. Is that correct?"
The expression on his face changed from one of authority and command to that of a little boy who had just gotten caught with his hand in the cookie jar.
He sheepishly replied, "Yes."
I then stated, "Well, sir, I have a real problem trying to imagine Pope John Paul commanding all Catholics to kill those of your faith or Dr. Stanley ordering Protestants to do the same in order to go to Heaven!"
The Imam was speechless.
I continued, "I also have problem with being your friend when you and your brother clerics are telling your followers to kill me. Let me ask you a question.
Would you rather have your Allah who tells you to kill me in order to go to Heaven or my Jesus who tells me to love you because I am going to Heaven and He wants you to be with me?"
You could have heard a pin drop.
Friday, April 16, 2004
Tuesday, March 30, 2004
NEWS RELEASE: For Immediate Release
Contact: Trent Loos, Faces of Agriculture 970-481-1389 or trent@loostales.com
Date: March 30, 2004
Farm Aid finances lawsuits against farm families
LOUP CITY, Neb. – Farm Aid, a non-profit organization founded by country music legend Willie Nelson to help struggling family farmers, is now funneling the money it generates toward anti-agricultural groups that file lawsuits against the very farmers Nelson claims to be helping, according to pro-agriculture crusader Trent Loos.
Nelson’s group has raised millions of dollars at Farm Aid concerts across the country since the organization began in 1985. More than $17 million has been contributed to various groups in 44 different states. But a recent investigation into these contributions revealed that much of the money is going to organizations engaged in litigation against farmers.
“It is an atrocity that someone can use the phrase ‘helping family farmers’ to generate millions of dollars and then turn around and use that money to finance the demise of those agricultural operations,” said Loos, founder of Faces of Agriculture. “People need to be aware of how their contributions to Farm Aid are really being used. This money is not helping farmers but litigating them out of business.”
For example: Farm Aid has funded the radical Illinois Stewardship Alliance, whose goal is to “protect the health and well-being of rural communities from the negative results of livestock production facilities.” Farm Aid also donates money to the Concerned Citizens of Iowa (CCI), a group that brags on its Web site, “At the local level, CCI helped pass factory farm moratoriums in four counties and passed ordinances in four other counties.” CCI has been instrumental in filing 14 lawsuits against farmers in Iowa, a record, for one group, according to Iowa Ag Law experts.
Funds generated under the auspices of helping farm families have also been donated to groups such as the Dakota Resource Council, Northern Plains Resource Council and the Western Organization of Resource Councils (WORC).
“These groups are working to prohibit development and research in the application of genetically modified crops,” Loos said, “developments that could potentially help mitigate world hunger problems and greatly reduce pesticide use.”
Farm Aid’s Web site includes numerous photos and passages from Farm Sanctuary, an organization that promotes a vegan and vegetarian lifestyle. In a recent CMT documentary about Farm Aid, “Voice for Animals” was listed in the credits. ”Voice for Animals” is an outspoken supporter for the “liberation” of all animals – including livestock.
“By propagating the myth of ‘factory farms’ and opposing technologies such as genetic modification and food irradiation -- developed to benefit of consumers and producers -- Farm Aid has taken a stand against farmers of all sizes, who are working to do what is best for the environment and the people they feed,” Loos said.
-30-
Faces of Agriculture is a non-profit organization with the mission of returning the human element to food production.
For more information, visit our Web site at www.FacesOfAg.com call 970-481-1389 or write to P.O. Box 545 Loup City, NE 68853
Contact: Trent Loos, Faces of Agriculture 970-481-1389 or trent@loostales.com
Date: March 30, 2004
Farm Aid finances lawsuits against farm families
LOUP CITY, Neb. – Farm Aid, a non-profit organization founded by country music legend Willie Nelson to help struggling family farmers, is now funneling the money it generates toward anti-agricultural groups that file lawsuits against the very farmers Nelson claims to be helping, according to pro-agriculture crusader Trent Loos.
Nelson’s group has raised millions of dollars at Farm Aid concerts across the country since the organization began in 1985. More than $17 million has been contributed to various groups in 44 different states. But a recent investigation into these contributions revealed that much of the money is going to organizations engaged in litigation against farmers.
“It is an atrocity that someone can use the phrase ‘helping family farmers’ to generate millions of dollars and then turn around and use that money to finance the demise of those agricultural operations,” said Loos, founder of Faces of Agriculture. “People need to be aware of how their contributions to Farm Aid are really being used. This money is not helping farmers but litigating them out of business.”
For example: Farm Aid has funded the radical Illinois Stewardship Alliance, whose goal is to “protect the health and well-being of rural communities from the negative results of livestock production facilities.” Farm Aid also donates money to the Concerned Citizens of Iowa (CCI), a group that brags on its Web site, “At the local level, CCI helped pass factory farm moratoriums in four counties and passed ordinances in four other counties.” CCI has been instrumental in filing 14 lawsuits against farmers in Iowa, a record, for one group, according to Iowa Ag Law experts.
Funds generated under the auspices of helping farm families have also been donated to groups such as the Dakota Resource Council, Northern Plains Resource Council and the Western Organization of Resource Councils (WORC).
“These groups are working to prohibit development and research in the application of genetically modified crops,” Loos said, “developments that could potentially help mitigate world hunger problems and greatly reduce pesticide use.”
Farm Aid’s Web site includes numerous photos and passages from Farm Sanctuary, an organization that promotes a vegan and vegetarian lifestyle. In a recent CMT documentary about Farm Aid, “Voice for Animals” was listed in the credits. ”Voice for Animals” is an outspoken supporter for the “liberation” of all animals – including livestock.
“By propagating the myth of ‘factory farms’ and opposing technologies such as genetic modification and food irradiation -- developed to benefit of consumers and producers -- Farm Aid has taken a stand against farmers of all sizes, who are working to do what is best for the environment and the people they feed,” Loos said.
-30-
Faces of Agriculture is a non-profit organization with the mission of returning the human element to food production.
For more information, visit our Web site at www.FacesOfAg.com call 970-481-1389 or write to P.O. Box 545 Loup City, NE 68853
Dear Editor,
If the voices of Ingrid Newkirk and Madeline Murray O’Hare can be heard and make a major impact on this country and the world, then so can mine!
My husband and I are CO-managers of two swine co-ops in northern Illinois. We love our jobs as farm managers and parents. Both of which are equally tasking in this day and age, mainly because we strive for excellence in all aspects of both jobs. At home we want our children to grow up strong, self-sufficient, nonjudgmental and tolerant of others. At work we want to be and train our employees to be good stewards of the environment and resource conservationists, and excellent animal welfare providers.
I have a hard time watching the evening news or reading the paper because more than the majority of information being given to me is about horrifying acts bad decisions and accidents that result in pain and suffering to others. The philosophy of “Blood, Gore and Smut Sells,” has become increasingly disturbing to me. I don’t want my children to grow up believing that what they see on television or read in the papers is the norm, just as I am tired of the bad press CAFO’s have received because the few bad acts and accidents that have occurred are being deemed “The Norm.”
Yes bad accidents have happened and unspeakable acts have also occurred within this industry, but that is absolutely not the norm. When we (members of the industry) are informed of a major accident or an individuals cruelty to animals, we are just as upset or appalled as the rest of the nation. Please don’t stereotype all pork producers as being cruel people or poor managers. To do so would be the same as classifying everyone who lives in Chicago as being murderers, rapists or child abusers, because that is all we hear about in the news. That sounds absurd doesn’t it!? But that is how I feel about “bad press.”
I am speaking out against all “Bad Press” and “Half-truth Activists” who only give us scary information and horrifying acts which feed the nation’s growing morbid curiosity. Activists against confinement operations have printed studies that say; approximately 25% of employees who work on confinement operations have one or more respiratory conditions. That is a half-truth. The study leaves out the fact that nationwide studies show that approximately 25% of the nations population in general have one or more respiratory conditions.
I know the people of this country who sign some of these crazy petitions are not ignorant, they just assume if it’s printed in the paper or on the news, it must be true. We need to take the time to ask more questions or look up this information for ourselves. We as a nation have become too tolerant of self-serving activists, that we are losing OUR RIGHT to Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness.
If you are going to STAND UP or SPEAK UP, please make all of the facts available. And if you are going to listen, please ask questions and look for other resources to become completely informed before following that crowd or signing that petition. We as a nation can not just stand by and let ourselves become victim to the self-righteous and self-serving.
I WON’T ANYMORE!
Sincerely,
Christine Grenter
Mendota, IL
If the voices of Ingrid Newkirk and Madeline Murray O’Hare can be heard and make a major impact on this country and the world, then so can mine!
My husband and I are CO-managers of two swine co-ops in northern Illinois. We love our jobs as farm managers and parents. Both of which are equally tasking in this day and age, mainly because we strive for excellence in all aspects of both jobs. At home we want our children to grow up strong, self-sufficient, nonjudgmental and tolerant of others. At work we want to be and train our employees to be good stewards of the environment and resource conservationists, and excellent animal welfare providers.
I have a hard time watching the evening news or reading the paper because more than the majority of information being given to me is about horrifying acts bad decisions and accidents that result in pain and suffering to others. The philosophy of “Blood, Gore and Smut Sells,” has become increasingly disturbing to me. I don’t want my children to grow up believing that what they see on television or read in the papers is the norm, just as I am tired of the bad press CAFO’s have received because the few bad acts and accidents that have occurred are being deemed “The Norm.”
Yes bad accidents have happened and unspeakable acts have also occurred within this industry, but that is absolutely not the norm. When we (members of the industry) are informed of a major accident or an individuals cruelty to animals, we are just as upset or appalled as the rest of the nation. Please don’t stereotype all pork producers as being cruel people or poor managers. To do so would be the same as classifying everyone who lives in Chicago as being murderers, rapists or child abusers, because that is all we hear about in the news. That sounds absurd doesn’t it!? But that is how I feel about “bad press.”
I am speaking out against all “Bad Press” and “Half-truth Activists” who only give us scary information and horrifying acts which feed the nation’s growing morbid curiosity. Activists against confinement operations have printed studies that say; approximately 25% of employees who work on confinement operations have one or more respiratory conditions. That is a half-truth. The study leaves out the fact that nationwide studies show that approximately 25% of the nations population in general have one or more respiratory conditions.
I know the people of this country who sign some of these crazy petitions are not ignorant, they just assume if it’s printed in the paper or on the news, it must be true. We need to take the time to ask more questions or look up this information for ourselves. We as a nation have become too tolerant of self-serving activists, that we are losing OUR RIGHT to Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness.
If you are going to STAND UP or SPEAK UP, please make all of the facts available. And if you are going to listen, please ask questions and look for other resources to become completely informed before following that crowd or signing that petition. We as a nation can not just stand by and let ourselves become victim to the self-righteous and self-serving.
I WON’T ANYMORE!
Sincerely,
Christine Grenter
Mendota, IL
Wednesday, March 17, 2004
Letters to the Editor llink to read at SquareDeal.com
'Tell Kennedy he is wrong' To the editor:
Everyone in Rawlins County should attend the speaking engagement of Robert F. Kennedy Jr., in Colby at 7 p.m., Thursday, March 11 at the Cultural Arts Center. If you have any involvement with Production Ag, you will want to attend. Kennedy has spoken around the world on the evils of Agriculture. What has incited me to encourage everyone to attend was an article in the March 8, 2004 issue of the High Plains Journal by Trent Loos entitled "The Black Hat Crew."
Loos followed Kennedy for eight weeks to listen to his inflammatory talks. According to Loos, "Kennedy stated numerous times in the months after Sept. 11, 2001, that pig farmers were a greater threat to the USA and democracy that bin Laden's terrorist network." Loos also heard, "The best thing would be if this industry (agriculture) did leave the country." Does not this so-called intelligent man (Kennedy) realize where his food comes from? If he thinks other countries can produce enough food to feed us, then why are they importing food and having food shortages?
Kennedy also has a strange way of classifying "factory farms." According to Loos, Kennedy defines factory farms as any farm that must obtain a permit to operate regardless of size, if you raise pigs that do not have access to bedding, or if beef or dairy cattle do not have access to grass at all times. Also according to his standards, any farmer who applies his own chemicals is a factory farm.
I plan on attending this talk. I feel that if we do not stand up to our critics and show that we know what we are doing, some outsider like Kennedy will come in and force changes on us or remove us. You may think that if we ignore these critics they will go away, but they will not. To do nothing is the same as giving up. If you love this land, show up in force and let Kennedy know that he is wrong and we will not take being given a black eye.
Andy Sramek
'Tell Kennedy he is wrong' To the editor:
Everyone in Rawlins County should attend the speaking engagement of Robert F. Kennedy Jr., in Colby at 7 p.m., Thursday, March 11 at the Cultural Arts Center. If you have any involvement with Production Ag, you will want to attend. Kennedy has spoken around the world on the evils of Agriculture. What has incited me to encourage everyone to attend was an article in the March 8, 2004 issue of the High Plains Journal by Trent Loos entitled "The Black Hat Crew."
Loos followed Kennedy for eight weeks to listen to his inflammatory talks. According to Loos, "Kennedy stated numerous times in the months after Sept. 11, 2001, that pig farmers were a greater threat to the USA and democracy that bin Laden's terrorist network." Loos also heard, "The best thing would be if this industry (agriculture) did leave the country." Does not this so-called intelligent man (Kennedy) realize where his food comes from? If he thinks other countries can produce enough food to feed us, then why are they importing food and having food shortages?
Kennedy also has a strange way of classifying "factory farms." According to Loos, Kennedy defines factory farms as any farm that must obtain a permit to operate regardless of size, if you raise pigs that do not have access to bedding, or if beef or dairy cattle do not have access to grass at all times. Also according to his standards, any farmer who applies his own chemicals is a factory farm.
I plan on attending this talk. I feel that if we do not stand up to our critics and show that we know what we are doing, some outsider like Kennedy will come in and force changes on us or remove us. You may think that if we ignore these critics they will go away, but they will not. To do nothing is the same as giving up. If you love this land, show up in force and let Kennedy know that he is wrong and we will not take being given a black eye.
Andy Sramek
Thursday, February 26, 2004
Proposed Iowa Air quaility standards
State Legislators raised questions last week about a proposed air quality rule
for hydrogen sulfide emissions from livestock operations. Last year, the DNR
established ambient air quality standards for hydrogen sulfide and ammonia for
all Iowa businesses including animal agriculture. In April of 2003, these
standards were nullified by the Iowa Legislature for two reasons. First, they
were based on faulty numbers and second, the DNR attempted to step beyond its
scope of authority.
Not to be deterred, the DNR has come forth this year with a"new" health
standard for hydrogen sulfide. That would be 15 parts per billion. This will be
the bar by which hydrogen sulfide will be measured against when the DNR embarks
on field studies later this year. If the 15 ppb (one hour average) is exceeded
more than seven times in a year, the DNR will be authorized to develop plans to
regulate any livestock operation.
The Iowa Farm Bureau Federation opposes such a standard. The DNR must hear this
message from you, the producer who will be affected by any new regulations set
forth. Iowa's pork producers are among the nations most regulated, if the Iowa
DNR has its way, the situation will only get worse.
Public hearing are being held now in regard to this issue. It is critical that
producers make their voices heard at these meetings! Plan to attend one of these
public hearings in your area!
March 3, 2004 at 6 P.M. at the Mason City Public Library, located at 225 2nd
Street SE in Mason City, Iowa.
March 8, 2004 at 6:30 P.M. at the Davenport Public Library, located at 321 Main
Street in Davenport, Iowa.
March 11, 2004 at 7 P.M. at the Urbandale Public Library, located at 3520 86th
Street in Urbandale, Iowa.
You may also send your written comments to
Bryan Bunton
Iowa DNR Air Quality Bureau
7900 Hickman Road
Urbandale IA 50322
Or e mail at bryan.bunton@dnr.state.ia.us
You may also fax comments to 515-242-5094
State Legislators raised questions last week about a proposed air quality rule
for hydrogen sulfide emissions from livestock operations. Last year, the DNR
established ambient air quality standards for hydrogen sulfide and ammonia for
all Iowa businesses including animal agriculture. In April of 2003, these
standards were nullified by the Iowa Legislature for two reasons. First, they
were based on faulty numbers and second, the DNR attempted to step beyond its
scope of authority.
Not to be deterred, the DNR has come forth this year with a"new" health
standard for hydrogen sulfide. That would be 15 parts per billion. This will be
the bar by which hydrogen sulfide will be measured against when the DNR embarks
on field studies later this year. If the 15 ppb (one hour average) is exceeded
more than seven times in a year, the DNR will be authorized to develop plans to
regulate any livestock operation.
The Iowa Farm Bureau Federation opposes such a standard. The DNR must hear this
message from you, the producer who will be affected by any new regulations set
forth. Iowa's pork producers are among the nations most regulated, if the Iowa
DNR has its way, the situation will only get worse.
Public hearing are being held now in regard to this issue. It is critical that
producers make their voices heard at these meetings! Plan to attend one of these
public hearings in your area!
March 3, 2004 at 6 P.M. at the Mason City Public Library, located at 225 2nd
Street SE in Mason City, Iowa.
March 8, 2004 at 6:30 P.M. at the Davenport Public Library, located at 321 Main
Street in Davenport, Iowa.
March 11, 2004 at 7 P.M. at the Urbandale Public Library, located at 3520 86th
Street in Urbandale, Iowa.
You may also send your written comments to
Bryan Bunton
Iowa DNR Air Quality Bureau
7900 Hickman Road
Urbandale IA 50322
Or e mail at bryan.bunton@dnr.state.ia.us
You may also fax comments to 515-242-5094
Tuesday, February 24, 2004
Press Release___________________________
For Immediate Release:
Contacts:
Dan Gunderson or Lauren Hankey 608-833-2040
February 20, 2004
Trent Loos, PETA’s Public Enemy Number One, will headline the Wisconsin Commercial Deer and Elk Farmers Association (WCDEFA) 2004 Annual Convention on Feb. 28 at the Holiday Inn Conference & Expo Center in Stevens Point, WI.
Loos is perhaps the most outspoken opponent to organizations against the consumption of meat. “The sensationalism of Bambi has gone on long enough in every segment of society. Human intelligence has led to more efficient and proper consumptive uses of our resources. Deer and Elk are living things. Everything that lives dies. Death with a purpose gives full meaning to life,” Loos said.
In addition to Loos, world-renowned Chef John Schumacher, from Schumacher’s Hotel in New Prague, MN will share with attendees his story, anecdotes and Schumacher’s Law- his common sense guide for living.
The keynote speaker will be Department of Natural Resources Secretary Scott Hassett.
The conventions includes breakfast and a luncheon featuring wild game such as venison chili and elk brats. In addition, there will be a bucket raffle and a silent auction. Admission is $50 and the public is invited.
Who: Wisconsin Commercial Deer and Elk Farmer Association
What: 12th Annual Convention
When: Saturday, February 28, 2004 at 8 a.m.
Where: Holiday Inn Conference & Expo Center in Stevens Point
Admission: $50 per person
The WCDEFA is an association for red deer, sika deer, fallow deer, reindeer and elk farmers in Wisconsin. Since the early ‘90’s, the WCDEFA has been a leader in the effort to seek higher regulatory standards for our industry.
Note: The WCDEFA will arrange for pre-interviews the week of Feb. 23 or the morning of the event with either Trent Loos or Chef John Schumacher.
For Immediate Release:
Contacts:
Dan Gunderson or Lauren Hankey 608-833-2040
February 20, 2004
Trent Loos, PETA’s Public Enemy Number One, will headline the Wisconsin Commercial Deer and Elk Farmers Association (WCDEFA) 2004 Annual Convention on Feb. 28 at the Holiday Inn Conference & Expo Center in Stevens Point, WI.
Loos is perhaps the most outspoken opponent to organizations against the consumption of meat. “The sensationalism of Bambi has gone on long enough in every segment of society. Human intelligence has led to more efficient and proper consumptive uses of our resources. Deer and Elk are living things. Everything that lives dies. Death with a purpose gives full meaning to life,” Loos said.
In addition to Loos, world-renowned Chef John Schumacher, from Schumacher’s Hotel in New Prague, MN will share with attendees his story, anecdotes and Schumacher’s Law- his common sense guide for living.
The keynote speaker will be Department of Natural Resources Secretary Scott Hassett.
The conventions includes breakfast and a luncheon featuring wild game such as venison chili and elk brats. In addition, there will be a bucket raffle and a silent auction. Admission is $50 and the public is invited.
Who: Wisconsin Commercial Deer and Elk Farmer Association
What: 12th Annual Convention
When: Saturday, February 28, 2004 at 8 a.m.
Where: Holiday Inn Conference & Expo Center in Stevens Point
Admission: $50 per person
The WCDEFA is an association for red deer, sika deer, fallow deer, reindeer and elk farmers in Wisconsin. Since the early ‘90’s, the WCDEFA has been a leader in the effort to seek higher regulatory standards for our industry.
Note: The WCDEFA will arrange for pre-interviews the week of Feb. 23 or the morning of the event with either Trent Loos or Chef John Schumacher.
Sunday, February 01, 2004
Letter to Editor-Tri State Neighbor Jan 23, 2004
Since Amendment E has come up as a topic of discussion once more, I feel
obliged to add some input to the discussion. Amendment E came into being in
spite of the opposition of every livestock and commodity group in the state
including the SD Pork Producers, SD Cattlemen, SD Sheep producers, SD
Soybean Growers, SD Corn Utilization Council, etc.
Dakota Rural Action accomplished this feat in the face of overwhelming
opposition from farm and ranch families through the unethical use of
blatantly false political advertising (remember the physteria ads and the
Smithfield bashing ads). These productions were paid for with huge sums of
out of state money, which DRA would have us believe they despise. These ads
offended and harmed everyone in the livestock industry, but they allowed DRA
to win through deception that which they could not win through logic or
science. While DRA rails against evils of outside capital in South Dakota
agriculture, the vast majority of its' money comes from enormous out of
state foundations.
As for the accomplishments of Amendment E, it failed to keep Murphy Farms
from partnering with some 200 farmers in the Midwest. Those hogs are still
marketed at the same plants that SD producer's hogs are. Amendment E did
keep SD corn farmers from benefitting from an annual ongoing multimillion
bushel corn market and likewise hurt all our soybean farmers. It resulted
in Iowa and Illinois taxpayers benefitting from many millions of dollars in
additional tax base while our schools, counties and state continued to
struggle to find dollars for services.
Farmers in every state around with anti-corporate farming laws (Nebraska,
North Dakota, and Minnesota) are unhappy with the unintended consequenses
stifling rural development and are working to rewrite those laws.
DRA wants to protect the small family farm from competition from larger
farms. If they could roll back the cost of living to what it was 30 years
ago, that goal would be feasible. The problem is that today's farmer must
pay today's health insurance, fuel, utilities, education, taxes, etc. and
every one of these bills will be higher tomorrow. Farm net income needs to
grow 6 percent per year to keep up with farm operating and family living
costs. The lifestyle that will attract a son or daughter to take on an
operation is not the lifestyle that grandpa endured. I make a living on two
quarters of land, but it is my Murphy contract that makes it possible.
South Dakota farmers have never been threatened by large scale
corporate-controlled factory farms (whatever that is). South Dakota law
does not allow out of state corporations to own agricultural real estate and
hasn't since the 1976 Family Farm Act. No out of state company can do
anything in South Dakota unless there is a beneficial partnership for the
farmer, and what is good for the farmer is good for the farm community.
Amendment E (1998) has been ruled unconstitutional thanks to the efforts of
every livestock and grain producer group in the state. Farm organizations
from Arkansas, Kansas, Kentucky, Minnesota, North Dakota, and Utah have
joined in because they recognize the threat to their farm communities as
well.
DRA refused to compromise during the last election on Amendment A. They
wanted Amendment E or nothing. Now they have nothing. So be it.
I think it is high time we let the farmer decide what is good for him and
what size and kind of operation will pay the bills. Having farm activists
dictating to us how we farm goes against every South Dakota tradition.
Oscar Wenholm Jr
Raymond, SD
Since Amendment E has come up as a topic of discussion once more, I feel
obliged to add some input to the discussion. Amendment E came into being in
spite of the opposition of every livestock and commodity group in the state
including the SD Pork Producers, SD Cattlemen, SD Sheep producers, SD
Soybean Growers, SD Corn Utilization Council, etc.
Dakota Rural Action accomplished this feat in the face of overwhelming
opposition from farm and ranch families through the unethical use of
blatantly false political advertising (remember the physteria ads and the
Smithfield bashing ads). These productions were paid for with huge sums of
out of state money, which DRA would have us believe they despise. These ads
offended and harmed everyone in the livestock industry, but they allowed DRA
to win through deception that which they could not win through logic or
science. While DRA rails against evils of outside capital in South Dakota
agriculture, the vast majority of its' money comes from enormous out of
state foundations.
As for the accomplishments of Amendment E, it failed to keep Murphy Farms
from partnering with some 200 farmers in the Midwest. Those hogs are still
marketed at the same plants that SD producer's hogs are. Amendment E did
keep SD corn farmers from benefitting from an annual ongoing multimillion
bushel corn market and likewise hurt all our soybean farmers. It resulted
in Iowa and Illinois taxpayers benefitting from many millions of dollars in
additional tax base while our schools, counties and state continued to
struggle to find dollars for services.
Farmers in every state around with anti-corporate farming laws (Nebraska,
North Dakota, and Minnesota) are unhappy with the unintended consequenses
stifling rural development and are working to rewrite those laws.
DRA wants to protect the small family farm from competition from larger
farms. If they could roll back the cost of living to what it was 30 years
ago, that goal would be feasible. The problem is that today's farmer must
pay today's health insurance, fuel, utilities, education, taxes, etc. and
every one of these bills will be higher tomorrow. Farm net income needs to
grow 6 percent per year to keep up with farm operating and family living
costs. The lifestyle that will attract a son or daughter to take on an
operation is not the lifestyle that grandpa endured. I make a living on two
quarters of land, but it is my Murphy contract that makes it possible.
South Dakota farmers have never been threatened by large scale
corporate-controlled factory farms (whatever that is). South Dakota law
does not allow out of state corporations to own agricultural real estate and
hasn't since the 1976 Family Farm Act. No out of state company can do
anything in South Dakota unless there is a beneficial partnership for the
farmer, and what is good for the farmer is good for the farm community.
Amendment E (1998) has been ruled unconstitutional thanks to the efforts of
every livestock and grain producer group in the state. Farm organizations
from Arkansas, Kansas, Kentucky, Minnesota, North Dakota, and Utah have
joined in because they recognize the threat to their farm communities as
well.
DRA refused to compromise during the last election on Amendment A. They
wanted Amendment E or nothing. Now they have nothing. So be it.
I think it is high time we let the farmer decide what is good for him and
what size and kind of operation will pay the bills. Having farm activists
dictating to us how we farm goes against every South Dakota tradition.
Oscar Wenholm Jr
Raymond, SD
Thursday, January 22, 2004
Join the Sierra Club, I did
In case you missed it yesterday, you might wonder “What in the world are you talking about, Trent?” Link to yesterday’s Loos Lips here. Gauging from your responses to this subject yesterday, no one thinks we are nuts and most are excited to help get this accomplished. Fur Commission has posted all the vital information you need in making this decision so act today. We must have this completed by Jan 31, 2004
Why join the Sierra Club? Click here. Choose the joint membership for two votes and I chose limited income. Following information available on Fur Commission website.
For as little as $32, a joint membership gives you TWO votes in what is a vital election. The Sierra Club is locked in a life and death battle for control of the Club's $100 million-dollar-a-year treasury.
The basic reason for this action is that Paul Watson is attempting to do the same thing. We can not afford to let Watson accomplish that. If you want to know why, check this out from ActivistCash.com.
"There’s nothing wrong with being a terrorist, as long as you win. Then you write the history."
Paul Watson, at the Animal Rights 2002 convention
And he is from a family of terrorists. His wife was arrested last week.
Animal-rights activist arrested
Case shines light on FBI's efforts to dismantle liberation fronts (more)
Thursday, January 15, 2004
By PAUL SHUKOVSKY
SEATTLE POST-INTELLIGENCER REPORTER
"There’s nothing wrong with being a terrorist, as long as you win. Then you write the history."
An agent with the FBI's domestic terrorism squad arrested an animal rights activist yesterday for allegedly lying to a Seattle federal grand jury investigating an arson attack on an Olympia forest-product company.
The complaint against Allison Lance Watson provides a rare window into the FBI's efforts to dismantle the Animal Liberation Front and Earth Liberation Front, which the bureau considers to be among the greatest domestic terrorism threats facing the nation.
Paul Watson, a celebrated defender of marine mammals and founder and president of the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society, spoke proudly of how his wife had not long ago been released from a Japanese jail were she was imprisoned for a short time for freeing numerous dolphins from nets. Watson said Sea Shepherd paid an $8,000 fine for his wife and one other activist. "That came out to about $600 per dolphin. We thought it was a good deal."
The LA Times laid the ground work in an article last week.
Link here.
Animal-rights activists and anti-immigration advocates are teaming in a bid to control the board, to the dismay of traditionalists.
By Miguel Bustillo and Kenneth R. Weiss
Los Angeles Times Staff Writers
January 18, 2004 An unusual alliance of anti-immigration advocates and animal-rights activists is attempting to take over the leadership of the Sierra Club, America's oldest national environmental group, in what is emerging as a bitter fight over the future of the 112-year-old organization founded by Scottish immigrant John Muir.
In response, 11 former Sierra Club presidents have written a letter expressing "extreme concern for the continuing viability of the club," protesting what they see as a concerted effort by outside organizations to hijack the mainstream conservationist group and its $95-million annual budget.
In case you missed it yesterday, you might wonder “What in the world are you talking about, Trent?” Link to yesterday’s Loos Lips here. Gauging from your responses to this subject yesterday, no one thinks we are nuts and most are excited to help get this accomplished. Fur Commission has posted all the vital information you need in making this decision so act today. We must have this completed by Jan 31, 2004
Why join the Sierra Club? Click here. Choose the joint membership for two votes and I chose limited income. Following information available on Fur Commission website.
For as little as $32, a joint membership gives you TWO votes in what is a vital election. The Sierra Club is locked in a life and death battle for control of the Club's $100 million-dollar-a-year treasury.
The basic reason for this action is that Paul Watson is attempting to do the same thing. We can not afford to let Watson accomplish that. If you want to know why, check this out from ActivistCash.com.
"There’s nothing wrong with being a terrorist, as long as you win. Then you write the history."
Paul Watson, at the Animal Rights 2002 convention
And he is from a family of terrorists. His wife was arrested last week.
Animal-rights activist arrested
Case shines light on FBI's efforts to dismantle liberation fronts (more)
Thursday, January 15, 2004
By PAUL SHUKOVSKY
SEATTLE POST-INTELLIGENCER REPORTER
"There’s nothing wrong with being a terrorist, as long as you win. Then you write the history."
An agent with the FBI's domestic terrorism squad arrested an animal rights activist yesterday for allegedly lying to a Seattle federal grand jury investigating an arson attack on an Olympia forest-product company.
The complaint against Allison Lance Watson provides a rare window into the FBI's efforts to dismantle the Animal Liberation Front and Earth Liberation Front, which the bureau considers to be among the greatest domestic terrorism threats facing the nation.
Paul Watson, a celebrated defender of marine mammals and founder and president of the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society, spoke proudly of how his wife had not long ago been released from a Japanese jail were she was imprisoned for a short time for freeing numerous dolphins from nets. Watson said Sea Shepherd paid an $8,000 fine for his wife and one other activist. "That came out to about $600 per dolphin. We thought it was a good deal."
The LA Times laid the ground work in an article last week.
Link here.
Animal-rights activists and anti-immigration advocates are teaming in a bid to control the board, to the dismay of traditionalists.
By Miguel Bustillo and Kenneth R. Weiss
Los Angeles Times Staff Writers
January 18, 2004 An unusual alliance of anti-immigration advocates and animal-rights activists is attempting to take over the leadership of the Sierra Club, America's oldest national environmental group, in what is emerging as a bitter fight over the future of the 112-year-old organization founded by Scottish immigrant John Muir.
In response, 11 former Sierra Club presidents have written a letter expressing "extreme concern for the continuing viability of the club," protesting what they see as a concerted effort by outside organizations to hijack the mainstream conservationist group and its $95-million annual budget.
We need you to join the Sierra Club
Many of you are going to think this is nuts. I fully endorse Teresa Platt and her plea to take over the Sierra Club. Act today. You always want to know how you can help so forward this to everyone you know.
Please do link here to read and understand the whole thing, we need to get a seat on the board.
Why my family joined the Sierra Club - and why yours should too before January 31, 2004!By Teresa Platt, Executive Director, Fur Commission USA (link)
I work in the mink biz and my family's work resumé includes agriculture and commercial fishing. Most of my friends are professional farmers, ranchers, fishermen, hunters and trappers, loggers and miners, whalers and sealers, resource providers from all over the world. Such people are more often on the receiving end of Sierra Club campaigns, as opposed to members of Sierra Club.So why has my family joined the Sierra Club?
Since most Sierra Clubbers don't vote, it only takes about 30,000 votes for a candidate to win a seat on the board. That's only 15,000 families with joint membership. Executive Director Carl Pope noted that 18% of Sierra Club members fish and/or hunt (about 140,000 of the 780,000 Sierra Club members) and he worries that they will be driven out of the Club by the vegan/animal rights agenda pushed by Paul Watson.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Nails it again
Once again Joyce Morrison has drawn the picture in the Illinois Leader so well.
The powerful push to protect animals (whole story)
By Joyce Morrison (jmorrison@illinoisleader.com)
Recently a cougar (mountain lion) in Orange County, CA killed one bicyclist and would have killed the second one if her companions had not come to her rescue. Estimates are between 4,000 and 6,000 adult lions roaming California. State law prohibits hunting or killing them.
There are environmentalists and then there are extremists. It would be interesting to put some of these extremists out in the wild for about two weeks to fend for themselves without mosquito spray and all the luxuries they enjoy while making their "pristine regulations." With no weapon to defend themselves against the wolves, poisonous snakes, cougars and bears they believe should be introduced into the rural areas where people live, their controls would become much less extreme.
Many of you are going to think this is nuts. I fully endorse Teresa Platt and her plea to take over the Sierra Club. Act today. You always want to know how you can help so forward this to everyone you know.
Please do link here to read and understand the whole thing, we need to get a seat on the board.
Why my family joined the Sierra Club - and why yours should too before January 31, 2004!By Teresa Platt, Executive Director, Fur Commission USA (link)
I work in the mink biz and my family's work resumé includes agriculture and commercial fishing. Most of my friends are professional farmers, ranchers, fishermen, hunters and trappers, loggers and miners, whalers and sealers, resource providers from all over the world. Such people are more often on the receiving end of Sierra Club campaigns, as opposed to members of Sierra Club.So why has my family joined the Sierra Club?
Since most Sierra Clubbers don't vote, it only takes about 30,000 votes for a candidate to win a seat on the board. That's only 15,000 families with joint membership. Executive Director Carl Pope noted that 18% of Sierra Club members fish and/or hunt (about 140,000 of the 780,000 Sierra Club members) and he worries that they will be driven out of the Club by the vegan/animal rights agenda pushed by Paul Watson.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Nails it again
Once again Joyce Morrison has drawn the picture in the Illinois Leader so well.
The powerful push to protect animals (whole story)
By Joyce Morrison (jmorrison@illinoisleader.com)
Recently a cougar (mountain lion) in Orange County, CA killed one bicyclist and would have killed the second one if her companions had not come to her rescue. Estimates are between 4,000 and 6,000 adult lions roaming California. State law prohibits hunting or killing them.
There are environmentalists and then there are extremists. It would be interesting to put some of these extremists out in the wild for about two weeks to fend for themselves without mosquito spray and all the luxuries they enjoy while making their "pristine regulations." With no weapon to defend themselves against the wolves, poisonous snakes, cougars and bears they believe should be introduced into the rural areas where people live, their controls would become much less extreme.
Wednesday, January 21, 2004
Why my family joined the Sierra Club - and why
yours should too before January 31, 2004!
By Teresa Platt, Executive Director, Fur Commission USA
I work in the mink biz and my family's work
resumé includes agriculture and commercial
fishing. Most of my friends are professional
farmers, ranchers, fishermen, hunters and
trappers, loggers and miners, whalers and
sealers, resource providers from all over the
world. Such people are more often on the
receiving end of Sierra Club campaigns, as
opposed to members of Sierra Club.
So why has my family joined the Sierra Club?
Because a joint membership purchased before
January 31, 2004 entitles our family to two votes
in the March 2004 Sierra Club board election. For
as little as $32, a joint membership gives you
TWO votes in what is a vital election. (1) The
Sierra Club is locked in a life and death battle
for control of the Club's $100
million-dollar-a-year treasury. (2)
The man leading the hostile takeover attempt is
Paul Watson, who claims to have invented tree
spiking and leads the eco-vigilantes of the Sea
Shepherd Conservation Society. Among crewmembers
on his rag-tag fleet of vegan vessels, Watson has
mentored convicted felon/arsonist Rodney Coronado
and Alex Pacheco, co-founder of People for the
Ethical Treatment of Animals (PeTA), plus dozens
of eco-anarchists with lengthy arrest records
earned via crimes committed globally. (3) 2004
started off with a bang for Sea Shepherd when
Watson's wife was arrested for lying to a grand
jury about use of a leased truck which appears to
have been used in the Pacific Northwest on an
eco-terrorist road trip. (4)
Watson claims he is now but three seats away from
controlling the 15-member Sierra Club board. (5)
Imagine the damage Watson, and the people he
supports, could do with access to hundreds of
millions of dollars!
Since most Sierra Clubbers don't vote, it only
takes about 30,000 votes for a candidate to win a
seat on the board. That's only 15,000 families
with joint membership. Executive Director Carl
Pope noted that 18% of Sierra Club members fish
and/or hunt (about 140,000 of the 780,000 Sierra
Club members) and he worries that they will be
driven out of the Club by the vegan/animal rights
agenda pushed by Watson.
"It's important to have hunters and fishermen in
the Sierra Club," Pope told the Los Angeles
Times. "We are a big-tent organization. We want
the Sierra Club to be a comfortable place for
Americans who want clean air, clean water, and to
protect America's open spaces."
Your joint membership must be in good standing by
January 31 to get your two votes in order to play
in this game!
SIDEBAR: To make this fray even more interesting,
the Southern Poverty Law Center, which has earned
respect for over twenty years of battling white
supremacists and the Ku Klux Klan, claims some of
the groups backing some of the Sierra Club board
and 2004 candidates have ties to racist groups.
The SPLC is so concerned by the turn of events,
its director, Morris Dees, is running for a seat
on the Sierra Club board, in order to "sound the
alarm." You must visit
www.splcenter.org/news/item.jsp?aid=45
NOTES:
(1) https://ww2.sierraclub.org/membership
(2) www.groundswellsierra.org
(3) www.activistcash.com
(4) http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/156710_animalrights15.html
(5) www.maninnature.com/Breaking/Watson.html
(6) See also "Election Becomes a Fight Over
Sierra Club's Future: Animal-rights activists and
anti-immigration advocates are teaming in a bid
to control the board, to the dismay of
traditionalists," Los Angeles Times, January 18,
2004,
http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-sierra18jan18,1,7295202.story?coll=la-home-headlines
yours should too before January 31, 2004!
By Teresa Platt, Executive Director, Fur Commission USA
I work in the mink biz and my family's work
resumé includes agriculture and commercial
fishing. Most of my friends are professional
farmers, ranchers, fishermen, hunters and
trappers, loggers and miners, whalers and
sealers, resource providers from all over the
world. Such people are more often on the
receiving end of Sierra Club campaigns, as
opposed to members of Sierra Club.
So why has my family joined the Sierra Club?
Because a joint membership purchased before
January 31, 2004 entitles our family to two votes
in the March 2004 Sierra Club board election. For
as little as $32, a joint membership gives you
TWO votes in what is a vital election. (1) The
Sierra Club is locked in a life and death battle
for control of the Club's $100
million-dollar-a-year treasury. (2)
The man leading the hostile takeover attempt is
Paul Watson, who claims to have invented tree
spiking and leads the eco-vigilantes of the Sea
Shepherd Conservation Society. Among crewmembers
on his rag-tag fleet of vegan vessels, Watson has
mentored convicted felon/arsonist Rodney Coronado
and Alex Pacheco, co-founder of People for the
Ethical Treatment of Animals (PeTA), plus dozens
of eco-anarchists with lengthy arrest records
earned via crimes committed globally. (3) 2004
started off with a bang for Sea Shepherd when
Watson's wife was arrested for lying to a grand
jury about use of a leased truck which appears to
have been used in the Pacific Northwest on an
eco-terrorist road trip. (4)
Watson claims he is now but three seats away from
controlling the 15-member Sierra Club board. (5)
Imagine the damage Watson, and the people he
supports, could do with access to hundreds of
millions of dollars!
Since most Sierra Clubbers don't vote, it only
takes about 30,000 votes for a candidate to win a
seat on the board. That's only 15,000 families
with joint membership. Executive Director Carl
Pope noted that 18% of Sierra Club members fish
and/or hunt (about 140,000 of the 780,000 Sierra
Club members) and he worries that they will be
driven out of the Club by the vegan/animal rights
agenda pushed by Watson.
"It's important to have hunters and fishermen in
the Sierra Club," Pope told the Los Angeles
Times. "We are a big-tent organization. We want
the Sierra Club to be a comfortable place for
Americans who want clean air, clean water, and to
protect America's open spaces."
Your joint membership must be in good standing by
January 31 to get your two votes in order to play
in this game!
SIDEBAR: To make this fray even more interesting,
the Southern Poverty Law Center, which has earned
respect for over twenty years of battling white
supremacists and the Ku Klux Klan, claims some of
the groups backing some of the Sierra Club board
and 2004 candidates have ties to racist groups.
The SPLC is so concerned by the turn of events,
its director, Morris Dees, is running for a seat
on the Sierra Club board, in order to "sound the
alarm." You must visit
www.splcenter.org/news/item.jsp?aid=45
NOTES:
(1) https://ww2.sierraclub.org/membership
(2) www.groundswellsierra.org
(3) www.activistcash.com
(4) http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/156710_animalrights15.html
(5) www.maninnature.com/Breaking/Watson.html
(6) See also "Election Becomes a Fight Over
Sierra Club's Future: Animal-rights activists and
anti-immigration advocates are teaming in a bid
to control the board, to the dismay of
traditionalists," Los Angeles Times, January 18,
2004,
http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-sierra18jan18,1,7295202.story?coll=la-home-headlines
Monday, January 19, 2004
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Media Contact: Ron Phillips
Office: (202) 662-4130
Data Demonstrate Little to No Evidence That Antibiotic Use
in Food Animals Presents Any Significant Risk to Human Health
-- New publication finds antibiotic bans not based on risk assessment may be more harmful to
human and animal health -
Washington, D.C. (January 19, 2004) – A new peer-reviewed article raises concern that the banning of antibiotics in food animals may harm both human and animal health. The report, published this month in the Journal of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy, found there is little to no scientific evidence to suggest that the use of antibiotics in food animals negatively impacts human health.
"The scientific evidence shows that the actual risk of transfer of antibiotic resistant organisms from animals to humans caused by the use of antibiotics in food animals is extremely small and in some cases zero," said Ian Phillips, M.D., principal author and Emeritus Professor of Medical Microbiology at the medical school of Guy's and St. Thomas' Hospitals, University of London. “The European Union applied the ‘Precautionary Principle’ and set aside scientific evidence, and so made decisions about antibiotics that have in fact damaged animal health and not provided any benefits to human health. We need to advance science and risk assessments to help make sound, evidence-based and balanced decisions in the United States and around the world.”
The panel of experts, drawn from both human and animal health, found the debate over the potential of antibiotic resistance transfer from animal to humans has featured misinformation and a blurring of important distinctions. They critically reviewed more than 250 studies and available data in an attempt to draw distinctions between events that do happen, may happen, might happen and do not happen.
Surveillance data from Europe and the United States shows numerous disconnects in the patterns of resistant bacteria in animals and humans, making it unlikely that there is or has been widespread transference of resistant bacteria via the food supply. And, while a European ban on antibiotics to promote growth has not reduced antibiotic resistance levels in humans in Europe, U.S. data shows the incident of antibiotic resistant food borne pathogens is generally declining as has the number of cases caused by food-borne bacteria.
“After examining the extensive surveillance data available, no significant benefits to human health as a result of European ban are evident, while it is clear that resistance in food borne pathogens has decreased in the U.S.,” said Ronald N. Jones, M.D., co-author of the JAC report and Principal Investigator of the SENTRY Antimicrobial Resistance Surveillance program, the world's largest database of antibiotic resistance.
A review of several risk assessments that have been conducted on specific antibiotics used in animals consistently showed extremely low levels of risk.
“We agree with the World Health Organization and the International Office of Epizootics that sound policy decisions must be based on scientific risk assessments that address the likely future human health consequences of proposed risk management actions. In practice, that means understanding and applying principles for prudent use of antibiotics and paying attention to surveillance and monitoring data for both antibiotic-susceptible and antibiotic-resistant illnesses caused by food-borne bacteria,” summarized Tony Cox, co-author and president of Cox Associates, an applied research company specializing in health risk analysis and operations research modeling. “Legislative and political efforts without sound science and quantitative assessment of their possible, adverse human health consequences are dangerous. If the United States follows the European ban then both animal and human health may be jeopardized.”
The report was developed by the independent advisory board to AHI, comprised of a group of human microbiologists, risk assessors, veterinarians and animal health experts, including Ian Phillips, M.D., FRCP, FRCPath, FFPHM, University of London; Ron Jones, M.D., The JONES Group/JMI Laboratories, North Liberty, IA; Mark Casewell, BSc, M.D., FRCP, FRCPath, University of London; Tony Cox, Ph.D., S.M., Cox Associates, an applied research company specializing in health risk analysis and operations research modeling, Denver, CO; Brad De Groot, M.S., D.V.M., Ph.D., Kansas State University, Manhattan, KS, and Livestock Information Services, Callaway, NE; Christian Friis, D.V.M, Ph.D., Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University, Copenhagen, Denmark; Charles Nightingale, M.S., Ph.D., Hartford Hospital, University of Connecticut, Hartford, CT; Rodney Preston, Ph.D., Texas Tech University, Lubbock, TX; and John Waddell, D.V.M., M.B.A., Sutton Veterinary Clinic, Sutton, NE.
“Continued use of antibiotics in food animals is important to animal health and welfare and food safety,” said Dr. John Waddell, D.V.M., a Nebraska veterinarian who has toured several Danish pigs farms. “We will continue to follow the principles of prudent use and rely on surveillance and risk assessment to ensure safe use of antibiotics to keep animals healthy.”
# # #
Media Contact: Ron Phillips
Office: (202) 662-4130
Data Demonstrate Little to No Evidence That Antibiotic Use
in Food Animals Presents Any Significant Risk to Human Health
-- New publication finds antibiotic bans not based on risk assessment may be more harmful to
human and animal health -
Washington, D.C. (January 19, 2004) – A new peer-reviewed article raises concern that the banning of antibiotics in food animals may harm both human and animal health. The report, published this month in the Journal of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy, found there is little to no scientific evidence to suggest that the use of antibiotics in food animals negatively impacts human health.
"The scientific evidence shows that the actual risk of transfer of antibiotic resistant organisms from animals to humans caused by the use of antibiotics in food animals is extremely small and in some cases zero," said Ian Phillips, M.D., principal author and Emeritus Professor of Medical Microbiology at the medical school of Guy's and St. Thomas' Hospitals, University of London. “The European Union applied the ‘Precautionary Principle’ and set aside scientific evidence, and so made decisions about antibiotics that have in fact damaged animal health and not provided any benefits to human health. We need to advance science and risk assessments to help make sound, evidence-based and balanced decisions in the United States and around the world.”
The panel of experts, drawn from both human and animal health, found the debate over the potential of antibiotic resistance transfer from animal to humans has featured misinformation and a blurring of important distinctions. They critically reviewed more than 250 studies and available data in an attempt to draw distinctions between events that do happen, may happen, might happen and do not happen.
Surveillance data from Europe and the United States shows numerous disconnects in the patterns of resistant bacteria in animals and humans, making it unlikely that there is or has been widespread transference of resistant bacteria via the food supply. And, while a European ban on antibiotics to promote growth has not reduced antibiotic resistance levels in humans in Europe, U.S. data shows the incident of antibiotic resistant food borne pathogens is generally declining as has the number of cases caused by food-borne bacteria.
“After examining the extensive surveillance data available, no significant benefits to human health as a result of European ban are evident, while it is clear that resistance in food borne pathogens has decreased in the U.S.,” said Ronald N. Jones, M.D., co-author of the JAC report and Principal Investigator of the SENTRY Antimicrobial Resistance Surveillance program, the world's largest database of antibiotic resistance.
A review of several risk assessments that have been conducted on specific antibiotics used in animals consistently showed extremely low levels of risk.
“We agree with the World Health Organization and the International Office of Epizootics that sound policy decisions must be based on scientific risk assessments that address the likely future human health consequences of proposed risk management actions. In practice, that means understanding and applying principles for prudent use of antibiotics and paying attention to surveillance and monitoring data for both antibiotic-susceptible and antibiotic-resistant illnesses caused by food-borne bacteria,” summarized Tony Cox, co-author and president of Cox Associates, an applied research company specializing in health risk analysis and operations research modeling. “Legislative and political efforts without sound science and quantitative assessment of their possible, adverse human health consequences are dangerous. If the United States follows the European ban then both animal and human health may be jeopardized.”
The report was developed by the independent advisory board to AHI, comprised of a group of human microbiologists, risk assessors, veterinarians and animal health experts, including Ian Phillips, M.D., FRCP, FRCPath, FFPHM, University of London; Ron Jones, M.D., The JONES Group/JMI Laboratories, North Liberty, IA; Mark Casewell, BSc, M.D., FRCP, FRCPath, University of London; Tony Cox, Ph.D., S.M., Cox Associates, an applied research company specializing in health risk analysis and operations research modeling, Denver, CO; Brad De Groot, M.S., D.V.M., Ph.D., Kansas State University, Manhattan, KS, and Livestock Information Services, Callaway, NE; Christian Friis, D.V.M, Ph.D., Royal Veterinary and Agricultural University, Copenhagen, Denmark; Charles Nightingale, M.S., Ph.D., Hartford Hospital, University of Connecticut, Hartford, CT; Rodney Preston, Ph.D., Texas Tech University, Lubbock, TX; and John Waddell, D.V.M., M.B.A., Sutton Veterinary Clinic, Sutton, NE.
“Continued use of antibiotics in food animals is important to animal health and welfare and food safety,” said Dr. John Waddell, D.V.M., a Nebraska veterinarian who has toured several Danish pigs farms. “We will continue to follow the principles of prudent use and rely on surveillance and risk assessment to ensure safe use of antibiotics to keep animals healthy.”
# # #
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Including link: https://blogs.loc.gov/
"I thought this was simply a nursery rhyme: how could one bake living birds in a pie? I discovered that royalty and the upper class, ...
-
As a 6 th generation United States farmer, I have had my fill of people talking about “humanely raised meat” when they don’t have a clue...
-
One huge step backwards for mankind Amazingly, we as individuals within an extremely informed society know more about less than ever before....